JournalEssay

The fallback ladder: why your playbook is wrong in the right direction

Elena RuizHead of Legal Engineering

· 9 min read

Every commercial playbook we have read says roughly the same thing about liability caps: start at the fees paid in the last twelve months, and escalate anything above that. Almost no firm actually closes there.

Over the last year we looked at 4,100 executed services agreements across the six firms in our pilots, together with the drafts exchanged on the way. For each of the 22 positions most often negotiated, we compared what the playbook said with where the deal landed.

The gap is not random

On liability caps, the stated position held in 31% of deals. That sounds like a playbook failing. But the other 69% did not scatter. They landed on a small number of steps, in the same order, at almost every firm:

Commercial services agreements, six firms, 2023 to 2026. Percentages are of deals where the cap was negotiated at all.

We call this the fallback ladder. Most firms have one. Very few have written it down, and when they have, it is usually in the head of one senior associate.

Wrong in the right direction

A playbook that states a position the firm rarely closes at is not useless. It is an anchor. Firms whose playbook opened at 1× and whose associates knew the ladder closed, on average, half a step lower than firms that opened at the first fallback. The stated position does its job by being slightly unrealistic.

The problem is not that the playbook is optimistic. It is that the ladder below it is invisible.

When the ladder is invisible, two things go wrong. Junior lawyers give away the second step before they have tried the first, because they do not know a first exists. And senior lawyers spend partner time re-deriving the ladder from memory on every deal.

What we changed in the product

Vellcite now shows the ladder next to the playbook position for every negotiated clause: the steps your firm has actually closed at, how often, and the most recent deal at each step. When a counterparty asks for the walk-away position first, the suggested counter is the next rung down, not the stated position.

PositionStated heldSteps on the ladder
Liability cap31%4
Payment terms44%3
Data protection indemnity58%2
Governing law87%1

Positions with a long ladder are where the time goes, and where a written ladder saves the most. Governing law almost never moves, and nobody needs software to tell them that.

Writing your own

You do not need Vellcite to start. Pick the five positions your group negotiates most, pull the last thirty executed agreements for each, and write down where they landed. The ladder usually appears by the twentieth deal. Then put it in the playbook, under the stated position, where the next associate can see it.

Find your own
fallback ladder.

Vellcite is in pilot with a small number of commercial teams in London and New York. Tell us what you negotiate most, and we’ll set one up on your own matters.